Free guide

How to compare kitchen renovation quotes, line by line

You have two or three quotes for the kitchen on the table. One is a few thousand less than the others, and they are all supposed to be the same job. The problem is not picking the cheapest. It is worked-out: what is actually different between them, and is the cheaper one really doing the same work?

This is a step-by-step way to line the quotes up so you can compare them honestly, then decide with confidence.

Why kitchen quotes are hard to compare

Kitchen quotes are rarely apples-to-apples, even for the “same” job. Differences creep in three ways:

• The scope is described differently. One quote itemises everything; the other gives a single sum for “cabinets and installation”.
• Assumptions are made silently. One contractor assumes standard cabinets, the other assumes a premium finish. The price gap may just be a spec gap.
• Lump sums hide the breakdown. A single “total” does not tell you where the money goes, so you cannot see what is driving the difference.

You cannot pick a winner until the quotes are on the same footing. So the first step is not to compare prices. It is to make them comparable.

Step 1 — Line up the scope first

Before you look at a single number, check that each quote is covering the same job:

• Same spec? Do all quotes assume the same cabinets, worktop, appliances and finish? If one assumes standard and another premium, part of the gap is just specification.
• Same inclusions? What is in: demolition, removal, waste and disposal, electrical and plumbing, final clean?
• Same exclusions? What is not in? A lower quote that leaves out the worktop or the appliances is not actually cheaper.

Write each quote’s scope down in the same words. Where two quotes assume different things, note it. Now you are comparing like with like.

Step 2 — Compare line by line

Once the scope matches, walk the quotes line by line, grouping the costs the same way every time:

• Labour — fitting and installation
• Materials and fixtures — cabinets, worktop, doors, handles
• Appliances
• Subcontractors — electrician, plumber, plasterer
• Waste and disposal
• Contingency or allowance — the money set aside for the unknown

Line by line, you can see where the quotes genuinely differ, and where one is simply more detailed than the other. A higher total often means more itemised, not more expensive.

Step 3 — Check the exclusions and the fine print

The real differences usually live here, not in the total:

• Payment schedule — how much is due up front, and when are the milestones? A large deposit before the work has started is a risk to weigh.
• Changes mid-job — what happens if you change your mind? Is there a rate or a process for change orders?
• If the job runs long — is there an agreed completion date, and what happens if it slips?
• Guarantee or warranty — what is covered, and for how long?
• Who does what — does the contractor manage the subcontractors, or do you?

Read this part before you sign. It is where two “similar” quotes become very different in practice.

Red flags in a kitchen quote

None of these means a contractor is bad. They mean you need more clarity before you commit:

• A single lump sum when you have asked for a breakdown.
• A total far below the others with no explanation of what was cut.
• Pressure for a large deposit before you have seen the full breakdown.
• Vague scope (“as required”, “to be confirmed”) on items that should be fixed.
• No agreed schedule, and no mention of what happens if the job runs long.

Before you sign, make sure the answers are in writing — see questions to ask a kitchen contractor.

---

Related: Kitchen renovation spreadsheet · What to look for in a kitchen renovation quote · How to budget a kitchen project · Kitchen renovation checklist · Planning a small kitchen layout